Guide

    Reporting line vs role-based approval: why the difference matters

    One of these makes the approval record evidence. The other makes it decoration.

    The short answer

    Should timesheet approval be based on roles or on the reporting line?

    Role-based approval grants every user with a Manager role authority over the whole organisation. Reporting-line approval derives authority from who actually reports to whom, so a manager can only review their own direct reports. The second is narrower, matches the real organisation chart, and is what makes an approval defensible in a dispute.

    The failure mode of role-based approval

    Give twelve people the Manager role and any of the twelve can sign off anyone’s hours. When a client disputes an invoice or an auditor asks who approved a period, "a manager did" is not an answer. The approval exists but carries no information about accountability.

    How reporting-line scoping works

    Each membership stores a link to its manager. A reviewer may act on an entry only if the entry’s owner’s manager link points at that reviewer — or if the reviewer is an Admin or Owner. In Flocci Timesheets that check is applied on single, team-view and bulk endpoints alike.

    Why the data layer, not the interface

    A scope rule enforced only in the interface is bypassed by the first person who calls the API directly or uses a bulk action. Enforcing it in the data layer — including silently filtering unauthorised entries out of bulk operations rather than partially failing — means there is no path that widens scope.

    What about matrix organisations

    One reporting line per membership is a deliberate simplification: multiple approvers usually means nobody is accountable. Where reporting genuinely splits, model it as separate workspaces — one person can hold independent memberships with different roles, rates and managers, and switch between them.

    Last reviewed 2026-10-20 by Flocci Technologies.

    Follow-up questions

    Do Admins still see everything?
    Yes, and that is intentional — somebody has to run payroll and organisation-wide reporting. The point is that Admin and Owner are a deliberate, separate grant rather than something the Manager role quietly includes.
    Does leave follow the same rule?
    In Flocci Timesheets, yes, since 2026-07-28. Before that any reviewer role could approve leave organisation-wide, which was inconsistent with how time entries had always worked; leave is now manager-scoped identically.
    Who can change a reporting line?
    Only an Admin or Owner, and the system validates that the proposed manager is in the same organisation and is not the member themselves. A Manager cannot reassign their way into a wider scope.

    Put the workflow to work.

    Draft → Pending → Approved, free at every team size, with no per-seat licence in the way.